The Goldilocks of trophic states

I’ve been writing about lakes as classified by trophic state: Oligotrophic (few nutrients), eutrophic (abundant or excessive nutrients) and mesotrophic (those in between).

No one of these trophic states is inherently “better” than the other. It’s to some extent a matter of personal preference, except that an extremely eutrophic (hypereutrophic) lake likely has serious water-quality issues. However, if I can be allowed an editorial opinion, I prefer to live on a mesotrophic lake, like our own Birch Lake at Harshaw.

Why? Because in many respects it mesotrophic is the best of all worlds – it is “just right.” A mesotrophic lake never gets seriously choked with weeds, nor does it typically see obnoxious late-summer algae blooms that cloud the water of eutrophic lakes. It is not as crystal clear as an oligotrophic lake, but it is reasonably clear, enough so to allow decent snorkeling, especially in June and July.

In general, mesotrophic lakes support more diverse plant, fish and other aquatic life than lakes in the other two trophic states. You won’t find cold-water fish like lake trout in mesotrophic lakes because the deep, cold water gets depleted of oxygen by late summer. However, these lakes can support excellent fisheries with panfish, largemouth and smallmouth bass, walleyes, northern pike and muskies (in varying proportions that depend on a host of other factors).

The trick with mesotrophic lakes is keeping them that way – that is, making sure that excessive nutrients (nitrogen and especially phosphorus) don’t get in and start tipping the scale toward the eutrophic side.

Nutrients get into lakes in various ways, and that in itself is not a bad thing. A creek flowing into your lake (as in the case of Birch Lake) almost certainly carries nutrients from decaying plants in the forests, marshes and fields through which it flows. That’s part of nature. The thing to avoid is needless nutrient enrichment from human sources.

Our mesotrophic lakes here in the north are typically surrounded by homes and cottages. Ideally, the property owners don’t dump fertilizers on their lawns and landscapes in excess amounts that run off into the water. And any fertilizers used should be phosphorus-free. So should any laundry or dish soaps the get discharged into septic tanks and ultimately dispersed through the soil.

Speaking of septic systems, they should be inspected regularly (a requirement here in Oneida County) to make sure they are functioning properly and not sending nutrients into ground or surface waters. Once excessive phosphorus gets into a lake, it is not readily flushed from the system. And then that lake is started on the path toward the eutrophic state. About which, more in a future column.